Wayne Krantz’s An Improviser’s OS is a short book with a plain cover and not a single diagram, fretboard or otherwise. You could read it in an afternoon. Getting it under your fingers takes a great deal longer, and that’s where most players come unstuck. It’s the most useful book on improvisation I own, on guitar or any other instrument, but only if you’re ready for it.
What’s in the book
Roughly half of it is formulas, which I’ll explain below. The other half is a conversation with Krantz about how to use them and, more importantly, why. That second half is what makes the book. The formulas on their own are just lists of numbers. The reasoning is what tells you what to do with them.
It’s a system for learning to improvise, arguably a method, but it’s a long way from CAGED, three-notes-per-string or any of the other approaches that claim to teach you the fretboard. There are no patterns in it at all.
The first edition came out in 2005. Krantz released a second edition in 2019, which he describes as almost a complete rewrite, with the core instructions clarified and material added from the years in between.
What’s a formula?
A formula is a set of notes taken from the twelve, written as intervals from a root. You improvise with those notes and only those notes, anywhere on the neck, moving around the fretboard by the intervals in the formula rather than by any shape.
Count every possible set of notes that includes the root and you get 2,048 formulas. A handful have names: the major scale, the minor pentatonic, the dominant seventh arpeggio. Most don’t, and that’s the point. You’re not learning scales. You’re learning to see any group of notes on the neck and make music out of it.
That can sound like scales with extra steps. It isn’t, because there’s nothing to memorise. You find the notes by knowing where they are, not by remembering a picture of where they were last time.
Why it’s different from pattern-based systems
Most fretboard systems give you patterns to learn and then spend the rest of your playing life teaching you how to get out of them. Krantz skips the patterns entirely.
The problem with a well-learned pattern is that it plays just as fluently whether you have an idea or not. That’s what drilling it was for. So a lot of what passes for improvising is really retrieval: the hands running something they already know while the ears go along with it. Working from formulas takes that option away. Every note has to be chosen, because there’s no shape to fall back on.
Who is this book for?
Players who can already get around the guitar and suspect their soloing has become more retrieval than invention. If you’ve noticed that your solos sound the same whatever you’re playing over, this book is about exactly that.
It isn’t tied to a style. Krantz is known for his own brand of fusion, but the method is about how you choose notes, not which genre you put them in. You don’t have to play like him to get something out of it.
It isn’t for beginners. You need to know the note names on the neck and what an interval is. Beyond that, there’s very little theory in it.
Why most players stall with it
The method is simple. Doing it is the hard part. Working out notes live is much slower than playing a shape you already know, and for the first few weeks you’ll sound worse than you did before. Most people who buy the book read it in one sitting, agree with every word, and never really apply it.
An Improviser’s OS assumes you’re ready to drop scales and think in note groups from day one. Most players aren’t, and that’s where the book loses them. If that sounds like you, my guide to learning to improvise on guitar gets you there more gradually: a few notes at a time, intervals instead of shapes, then playing over chord changes.
The other thing that helps is drilling the skill underneath the method, which is finding any interval from any root without a diagram. The free Interval Trainer was built for exactly that. It gives you a root and an interval and nothing else, so you have to find the note on the guitar yourself.
A simpler way in
No Shapes started as my attempt at a much simpler book along the same lines. It takes the same starting point, everything from intervals with no boxes, and cuts it down to one octave shape, one interval map, the formulas you’ll actually use, and a 30-day plan. It isn’t a replacement for Krantz. Think of it as the step before.
If you’d rather try the idea before reading anything, Riff Cells deals you a random set of notes over a root and chord, which is close to a formula chosen for you. The challenge is the same: make music from those notes and nothing else.
Where to buy it
Krantz sells the book himself. The second edition is on his Bandcamp page. Buy it from him rather than a reseller.
Don’t rush it. You can read it in a sitting, but I carried my copy around for about three weeks and read it a few pages at a time, which is the right speed for it. Krantz is clear about how to apply the material, so you’re not left guessing. You just have to do the work.
Like Allan Holdsworth, Krantz took a very simple idea and followed it further than anyone else. This book is that idea, written down.
